Religious Concept of Power as a Problem of Russian Political Culture: “Bargradsky Project” (On the Issue of Alternatives to Russian History)
https://doi.org/10.30727/0235-1188-2019-62-4-25-43
Abstract
In this article, the author analyzes the concept of religious foundations of culture and power as a problem of Russian political consciousness. The paper reveals the patterns of interaction between the religious and political traditions of the Russian Empire in the early 20th century. The author provides Bargradsky project case as a unique example of such influence, identifying its mean in the later Russian Empire’s political history. Philosophical-political case that is analyzed in the article makes it possible to trace the inner links between religious attitudes and political imagination of Russian monarchical circles and to identify the peculiarities of religious and political self-awareness of Russian power, its mechanisms for the selecting the ideas, symbols, images of the national political, religious and artistic culture in the last period of the Russian Empire. From our point of view, it would be most effective to combine the cultural-historical and the philosophical and historical approaches both in the reconstruction of Bargradsky project and in studies of Russian political culture. The article examines both the political conditions of activities and spiritual-cultural goals of Bargradsky Committee on Bargradsky project in Italian Bari as well as in Saint Petersburg in the 1910s. The author discusses the religious concept of Russian political culture, applying philosophical-historical method for the analyses Bargradsky Committee activity and its attempt to slow down the degradation of the Russian autocracy. The major emphasis is placed on the political and philosophical way of analysis as well as on the possibility of introducing the results of philosophical-historical research into current debates on the issue of alternatives to Russian history.
Keywords
About the Author
O. A. ZhukovaRussian Federation
Olga Zhukova – D.Sc. in Philosophy, Professor at the School of Philosophy, Faculty of Humanities
Moscow
References
1. Almond G. & Verba S. (1963) The Civic Culture. Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
2. Antonov V.V. & Kobak A.V. (2010) Shrines of St. Petersburg. Encyclopedia of Christian churches. Saint Petersburg: Liki Rossii (in Russian).
3. Berar E. (2016) Empire and City. Nicholas II, “World of Art” and the City Duma in Saint Petersburg. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie (in Russian).
4. Berdyaev N.A. (1994) New Middle Ages. In: Berdyaev N.A. Philosophy of Creativity, Culture and Art. In 2 Volumes (vol. 1, pp. 406 – 464). Moscow: Iskusstvo (in Russian).
5. Boytsov M.A. & Exsle O.G. (Eds.) (2008) Images of Power in the West, Byzantium and Russia: The Middle Ages. New Times. Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).
6. Boytsov A. & Talalay M.G. (2011) Patriarch’s Courtyard of St. Nicholas in Bari. History. Decoration. Mission. Moscow: Indrik (in Russian).
7. Bychkov S.S. (1998) Russian Church and Imperial power (Essays on the History of the Orthodox Russian Church in 1900–1917). Moscow: Russkoe reklamnoe izdatel’tvo (in Russian).
8. Dmitrievsky A.A. (1916) Sanctification of Bargradsk Nikolo-Aleksandrovsk Temple in Petrograd. In: Soobshcheniya Imperatorskogo Pravoslavnogo Palestinskogo Obshhestva.Vol. 27 (in Russian).
9. Ekonomtsev I. (1992) National-Religious Ideal and Idea of Empire in Peter’s Epoch. In: Orthodox. Byzantium. Russia. Works. Moscow: Khristianskaja literatura (in Russian).
10. Evstratova M.V. & Koluzakov S.V. (2017) Church of St. Nicholas in Bari. Project of Architect A. V. Shchusev. Moscow: Kuchkovo Pole; ABCdesign (in Russian).
11. Gerd L.A. (2006) Constantinople and St. Petersburg: Church Policy of Russia in the Orthodox East (1878–1898). Moscow: Indrik (in Russian).
12. Karpov A.V. & Tachintsev A.I. (Eds.) (2006) Empire and Religion. The 100 th Anniversary of the St. Petersburg Religious-Philosophical Meetings of 1901–1903: Materials of All-Russian Conference. Saint Petersburg: Aleteya (in Russian).
13. Kokovtsov V.N. (1933) From My Past. Memoirs, 1913-1919: in 2 Volumes. Vol. 2. Paris: Illyustrirovannaya Rossiya (in Russian).
14. Kovyrzev K.V. (Ed.) (2009) 1917: The Church and the Destiny of Russia. On the 90th Anniversary of the Local Council and the Election of Patriarch Tikhon.Moscow: Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius Pub. (in Russian).
15. Lisovoy N.N. (2006) Russian Spiritual and Political Presence in the Holy Land and the Middle East in the 19th – Early 20 th Centuries. Moscow: Indrik (in Russian),
16. Lidov A.M. (Ed.) (2006) New Jerusalem. Transfer of Sacred Spaces in Christian Culture. Proceedings of the international Symposium. Moscow: Indrik (in Russian).
17. Miller A. (2008) Romanov’s Empire and Nationalism: An Essay on the Methodology of Historical Research. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie (in Russian).
18. Mrowczynski-Van Allen A., Obolevitch T., & Rojek P. (Eds.) (2015) Apology of Culture. Religion and Culture in Russian Thought. Eugene, OR: Pickwick Publications.
19. Ponkratova E.N. (Comp.) (2015) Letters of the Martyr Grand Duchess Elizabeth Feodorovna. Moscow: Letopis (in Russian).
20. Tyrkova-Williams A.V. (2007) On the Ways to Freedom. Moscow: Moscow School of Political Research Pub. (in Russian).
21. Simansky A. (2005) Metropolitan Filaret on Church and state.Sergiev Posad: Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius Pub. (in Russian).
22. Shchusev A.V. (1914) Pilgrim’s House and Church in the Name of St. Nicholas of Myra in Bari, in Italy. Zodchiy. 1914. No. 3. (in Russian).
23. Struve P.B. (1997) Patriotica: Politics, Culture, Religion, Socialism. Moscow: Respublika (in Russian).
24. Talalay (2011) Russian Church Life and Church Building in Italy. Saint Petersburg: Kolo (in Russian).
25. Tumanova A.S. (2014) Public Organizations of Russia During the First World War (1914 – February 1917). Moscow: ROSSPEN (in Russian).
26. Zhukova O.A. (2014) Selected Works on the Philosophy of Culture. Cultural Capital. Russian Culture and Social Practices of Modern Russia. Moscow: Soglasie (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Zhukova O.A. Religious Concept of Power as a Problem of Russian Political Culture: “Bargradsky Project” (On the Issue of Alternatives to Russian History). Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences. 2019;62(4):25-43. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.30727/0235-1188-2019-62-4-25-43