Preview

Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences

Advanced search

The Philosophy of War: Unity in Diversity

https://doi.org/10.30727/0235-1188-2020-63-1-20-39

Abstract

The article discusses the diversity of the subject field of the philosophy of war as well as the internal integrity of the discipline, united by the focus on the philosophical understanding of the phenomenon of war. The author shows the role of H. Lloyd, who influenced K. Clausewitz, H. Jomini and their followers’ interpretation of the meaning and content of the subject area of the philosophy of war. In the abundance of specific topics addressed by philosophers of this field, the following topics should be noted: the issue of victory and defeat and their interpretation as well as the issue of historical memory. This problem is projected on contemporaneity and reflects the deep connection between peace and war, the dialectic of their relations. The interpretation of certain military and political events is of real interest in the light of the processes of distortion of historical events that have radically affected the course of history. An analysis of the motives and causes of this process is supposes to reconstruct an objective picture of relations between the subjects of international relations in various periods of history. The author finds answers in already existing concepts that have been developed in our time. It is important to mention the project of the French philosopher Charles Renouvier, who put forward the concept of “uchronia,” which became the starting point for the consideration of historical events in the “subjunctive mood.” This genre of historiosophical fantasy was picked up by famous followers – by the former President of France V. Giscard d’Estaing and others. The article provides eyewitness accounts of historical events (in particular, the campaign of Napoleon in Russia) that are historical facts and help to understand the true state of things. The article demonstrates that the philosophical study of the problem of war is important for understanding the origins and essence of relations arising from the transition between peaceful and military states.

About the Author

Alexey V. Soloviev
Lomonosov Moscow State University
Russian Federation

Ph.D. in Philosophy, Associate Professor of the Department of the Philosophy of Politics and Law, Faculty of Philosophy



References

1. Belkov O.A. (2019) Philosophy of War: Words and Meanings. Vlast’. No. 2, pp. 119–127 (in Russian).

2. Belozerov V. (2018a) Politische Theorie des Krieges bei Carl von Clausewitz und Carl Schmitt aus russischer Sicht (Teil 1). Österreichische militärische Zeitschrift. No. 1, pp. 12–23 (in German).

3. Belozerov V. (2018b) Politische Theorie des Krieges bei Carl von Clausewitz und Carl Schmitt aus russischer Sicht (Teil 2). Österreichische militärische Zeitschrift. No. 2, pp. 147–157 (in German).

4. Bezotosny V.M. (2004) Napoleon’s Intelligence Service in the Campaign of 1812. Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya. No. 4, pp. 190–202 (in Russian).

5. Bogdanovich M.I. (1859) History of the Patriotic war of 1812, According to Reliable Sources (Vol. 1). Saint Petersburg: S. Strugovschik, G. Pokhitonov, N. Vodova and Co. (in Russian).

6. Chalvardjian E. (2014) Impact de l’art de la guerre napoléonien dans la seconde moitié du XIX e siècle. Paris: Publibook (in French).

7. Chambray G. (1829) Philosophie de la guerre (2 nd ed.). Paris: Pillet aîné (in French).

8. Clausewitz K. (1997) On war. Moscow (Russian translation).

9. Danilenko I. S. (2008a) From Applied Military Science – To the System Science of War (Beginning). Voyennaya mysl’. No. 10, pp. 23–26 (in Russian).

10. Danilenko I. S. (2008b) From Applied Military Science – To the System Science of War (End). Voyennaya mysl’. No. 11, pp. 18–27 (in Russian).

11. Danilevsky N.Y. (1998) Woe to the Winners. In: Danilevsky N.Y. Political Articles. Moscow: Alir; Oblizdat.

12. Freund J. (2008) Victory and Defeat. Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 12. Political Sciences. No. 6, pp. 58–66 (Russian translation).

13. Giscard d’Estaing V. (2010) La Victoire de la Grande Armée. Paris: Plon, 2010 (in French).

14. Glinka F.N. (2012) Description of the Patriotic War of 1812 before the Expulsion of the Enemy from Russia and the Transition Abroad in 1813. In: Letters of a Russian Officer. Memoirs of Participants in the War of 1812 (pp. 91–154). Moscow: Avanta+; Astrel (in Russian).

15. Illas E. (2020) The Survival Regime. Global War and the Political. New York: Routledge.

16. Kozikov I.A. (2018) D.I. Mendeleev Is Not only a Chemist. Moscow: Moscow University Press (in French).

17. Labaume E. (1820) Relation complète de la Campagne de Russie, en 1812. Paris: Janet et Cotelle Librairies (in French).

18. Lloyd H. (1790) La Philosophie de la guerre. Extrait des Mémoires politiques et militaires du général Lloyd, traduit par un officier français. Paris: Barrois l’aîné (French translation).

19. Navia-Osorio y Vigil Á. (1738) Reflexions Militaires et Politiques (M. de Vergy, Trans.). – Paris: Hippolyte-Louis Guerin (French translation).

20. Philonenko A. (1976) Essai sur la philosophie de la guerre. Paris: J. Vrin (in French).

21. Plato (1971). Republic. In: Plato. Works in 3 Vols. (Vol. 3, part 1). Moscow: Mysl’ (Russian translation).

22. Plato (1972). Laws. In: Plato. Works in 3 Vols. (Vol. 3, part 2). Moscow: Mysl’ (Russian translation).

23. Rey M.-P. (2012) L’Effroyable Tragédie: Une nouvelle histoire de la campagne de Russie. Paris: Flammarion (in French).

24. Ségur P.P. (1910) La Campagne de Russie. Paris: Nelson (in French).

25. Steinmetz S.R. (1907) Die Philosophie des Krieges. Leipzig: Bart (in German).

26. Sun-Tzu (2002). Treatises on the Art of War. Moscow: AST.

27. Tarle E.V. (2015) Borodino. Moscow: Direkt-Media (in Russian).

28. Zemtsov V.N. (2002) “French” Borodino. French Historiography of the Battle of Borodino. Otechestvennaya istoriya. No. 6, pp. 38–51 (in Russian).

29. Zotkin A.A. (2016) Problem of War and Peace in the Works of Kant, Fichte, and Hegel. Bulletin of the Moscow State Regional University. No. 4 (in Russian).


Review

For citations:


Soloviev A.V. The Philosophy of War: Unity in Diversity. Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences. 2020;63(1):20-39. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.30727/0235-1188-2020-63-1-20-39



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 0235-1188 (Print)
ISSN 2618-8961 (Online)