The Problem of Understanding in Russian Idealism of the Late 19^th and Early 20^th Centuries: V.S. Solovyov and S.N. Trubetskoy

The paper examines the doctrine of understanding in Russian idealism from the late 19^th to early 20^th century. The author discusses the main ontological and epistemological concepts in the philosophy of V.S. Solovyov and his follower S.N. Trubetskoy. The paper offers a historical and philosophical reconstruction of the concept of understanding based on the analysis of V.S. Solovyov's Lectures on Divine Humanity and S.N. Trubetskoy's work On the Nature of Human Consciousness. According to Solovyov, the study of understanding is possible if we presume an unconditional principle that premises being as the One. Based on this premise, it is demonstrated that the unconditional principle allows to know everything without having knowledge of each subject separately, and this, in turn, is understanding process. Trubetskoy's theory of understanding is premised on the concept of soborny (gathered) mind, which defines mind as joint knowledge about all spheres of existence. The article shows that the main position shared by the Russian thinkers is the unconditional principle serving as the basis for life and mind without which the existence of either the universal or the particular is impossible. The author concludes that such a principle is a cognitive relation to the world, which unconditionality is the condition for understanding the reality as indivisible. Understanding, as presented by V.S. Solovyov and S.N. Trubetskoy, is the true understanding of the unity of existence in all its manifestations, that is, a synthesis of the sensual, rational, moral, and aesthetic.

1. Akulinin V.N (1990) Philosophy of All-Unity: From V.S. Soloviev to P.A. Florensky. Novosibirsk: Nauka (in Russian)

2. Dilthey W. (2000) Introduction to the human Sciences. In: Dilthey W. Collected Works in 6 Vols. (Vol. 1, pp. 279-709). Moscow: Dom intellektual'noy knigi (in Russian).

3. Ern V.F. (1991) Something on Logos, Russian Philosophy and Science. In: Ern V.F. Works (pp. 71 - 109). Moscow: Pravda (in Russian).

4. Gordon E.C. (2012) Is There Propositional Understanding? Logos & Episteme. Vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 181 - 192.

5. Levinas E. (2017) Notes on the Sense. In: Sholokhova S.A. & Yampol'skaya A.V. (Comp.) (Post)Phenomenology: New Phenomenology in France and Beyond (pp. 18-39). Moscow: Akademicheskiy proyekt (Russian translation).

6. Losev A.F. (1991) Russian Philosophy. In: Emelyanov B.V. & Lyubutin K.N. (Comp.) Essays on the history of Russian Philosophy (pp. 67-96). Sverdlovsk: Ural State University (in Russian).

7. Lossky N.O. (2007a) history of Russian Philosophy. Moscow: Akademicheskiy proyekt (in Russian).

8. Lossky N.O. (2007b) Characteristic Features of Russian Philosophy. In: Lossky N.O. History of Russian Philosophy (pp. 539-548). Moscow: Akademicheskiy proyekt (in Russian).

9. Marion J.-L. (2017) The Saturated Phenomenon. In: Sholokhova S.A. & Yampol'skaya A.V. (Comp.) (Post)Phenomenology: New Phenomenology in France and Beyond (pp. 63-100). Moscow: Akademicheskiy proyekt (Russian translation).

10. Rozanov V.V. (2006) On Understanding. Experience in the Study of Nature, Limits, and Internal Structure of Science as a Whole Knowledge. Moscow: St. Thomas Institute of Philosophy, Theology and history (in Russian).

11. Shpidlik T. (2006) Russian Idea: A Different Vision of Man. Saint Petersburg: Oleg Abyshko Publishing (in Russian).

12. Solovyovv V.S. (2018) Lectures on Divine humanity. Moscow: Ripol klassik (in Russian).

13. Teslya A.A. (2018) Originator. In: Solovyov V.S. Lectures on Divine humanity (pp. I-XXIII). Moscow: Ripol klassik (in Russian).

14. Trubetskoy S.N. (1994) On the Nature of Human Consciousness. In: Trubetskoy S.N. Works (pp. 483-593). Moscow: Mysl' (in Russian).

15. Whitcomb D. (2012) Epistemic Value. In: Cullison A. (Ed.) The Continuum Companion to Epistemology (pp. 270 - 288). New York: Continuum Press.

16. Zhukova O.A. (2017) Philosophy of Russian Culture. Metaphysical Perspective of Man and history. Moscow: Soglasiye (in Russian).

17. Zhukova O.A. (2019) Experience of Russian culture. Philosophy of history, Literature and Art. Moscow: Soglasiye (in Russian).