Meditation as a Cultural Practice: A Cultural-Historical Activity Perspective

The paper discusses some challenges from meditation studies which might be analyzed within the framework of cultural-historical activity approach in psychology. The special focus of the paper is attention and its status as an independent mental process. This problem produced two classes of attentional theories in the history of psychology: «cause theories» and «effect theories». The two classes of theories are confronted as related to human perceptual activity within the framework of the activity theory proposed by Alexey Leontiev and the physiology of activity developed by Nikolai Bernstein. «Cause theories» and «effect theories» are analyzed both theoretically and in the light of experimental studies of the so-called «attentional blink» phenomenon. This transient attentional error under rapid serial visual presentation conditions, first described 25 years ago, has become a ground for the confrontation of various models and theories of attention. At the same time, it has become an object of the keen interest of meditation and mindfulness researchers. The facts of the attentional blink decrease due to the change of the structure of perceptual activity are compared to the facts of the similar attentional blink decrease after the meditation retreat. The problem of the nature of internal cultural means mediating meditation and mindfulness practices is raised as a result of the whole discussion.

сознание, внимание, медитация, культурно-историческая психология, психологическая теория деятельности, физиология активности, «мигание внимания», consciousness, attention, meditation, cultural-historical psycho-logy, activity theory in psychology, physiology of activity, attentional blink

1. Бернштейн Н.а. Очерки о физиологии движений и физиологии активности. - М.: Медицина, 1966.

2. Величковский Б.М. От уровней обработки к стратификации познания // Вопросы психологии. 1999. № 4. С. 58-74.

3. Вундт В. Введение в психологию. - М.: Космос, 1912. Выготский 1983 - Выготский Л.С. Собр. соч. В 6 т. Т. 3. - М.: Педагогика, 1983.

4. Гиппенрейтер Ю.Б. Деятельность и внимание // А.Н. Леонтьев и современная психология / под ред. А.В. Запорожца и др. - М.: Изд-во Моск. ун-та, 1983. С. 165-177.

5. Зинченко В.П., Моргунов Е.Б. Человек развивающийся. Очерки российской психологии. - М.: Тривола, 1994.

6. Ланге Н.Н. Психологические исследования. Закон перцепции. Теория волевого внимания. - Одесса, 1893.

7. Леонтьев А.Н. Деятельность, сознание, личность. - М.: Политиздат, 1975.

8. Лысенко В.Г. Виджняна. Манасикара. Медитация в буддизме // Философия буддизма. Энциклопедия / отв. ред. М.Т. Степанянц. - М.: Восточная литература, 2011. С. 210-216, 432, 463-469.

9. Патяева Е.Ю. Порождение действия. Культурнодеятельностный подход к мотивации человека. - М.: Смысл, 2018.

10. Романов В.Я., Дормашев Ю.Б. Постановка и разработка проблемы внимания с позиций теории деятельности // Вестник Моск. ун-та. Серия 14. Психология. 1993. № 2. С. 51-62.

11. Сироткина И.Е. Роль исследований Николая Александровича Бернштейна в развитии отечественной психологической науки. Дисс. … канд. психол. наук. - М., 1989.

12. Титченер Э. Учебник психологии / пер. с англ. А.П. Болтунова. - М.: Мир, 1914.

13. Фаликман М.В. Уровневые эффекты внимания в условиях быстрой смены зрительных стимулов // Ученые записки кафедры общей психологии МГУ. Вып. 1 / под ред. Б.С. Братуся, Д.А. Леонтьева. - М.: Смысл, 2002. С. 365-376.

14. Фаликман М.В. Новая волна Выготского в когнитивной науке: разум как незавершенный проект // Психологические исследования. 2017. Т. 10. № 54. С. 2. - URL: http://psystudy.ru (дата обращения: 11.02.2018).

15. Фаликман М.В., Печенкова Е.В. Принципы физиологии активности Н.А. Бернштейна в психологии восприятия и внимания: проблемы и перспективы // Культурно-историческая психология. 2016. Т. 12. № 4. С. 48-66.

16. Afonso R.F., Balardin J.B., Lazar S., Sato J.R., Igarashi N., Santaella D.F., Lacerda S.S., Amaro E. Jr., Kozasa E.H. Greater cortical thickness in elderly female Yoga practitioners - a cross-sectional study // Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience. 2017. Vol. 9. P. 201.

17. Anderson B. There is no such thing as attention // Frontiers in Psychology. 2011. Vol. 2. P. 246.

18. Braboszcz C., Cahn B.R., Balakrishnan B., Maturi R.K., Grandchamp R., Delorme A. Plasticity of visual attention in Isha yoga meditation practitioners before and after a 3-month retreat // Frontiers in Psychology. 2013. Vol. 4. P. 914.

19. Brefczynski-Lewis J.A., Lutz A., Schaefer H.S., Levinson D.B., Davidson R.J. Neural correlates of attentional expertise in long-term meditation practitioners // Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA. 2007. Vol. 104. P. 11483-11488.

20. Brown K., Cole M. Cultural Historical Activity Theory and the Expansion of Opportunities for Learning After School. In: Wells G., Claxton G. (eds.) Learning for Life in the 21 st Century: Sociocultural Perspectives on the Future of Education. - Blackwell Publ., 2008. Р. 225-238.

21. Carrasco M. Covert attention increases contrast sensitivity: Psychophysical, neurophysiological and neuroimaging studies // Progress in Brain Research. 2006. Vol. 154. P. 33-70.

22. Carter O.L., Presti D.E., Callistemon C., Ungerer Y., Liu G.B., Pettigrew J.D. Meditation alters perceptual rivalry in Tibetan Buddhist monks // Current Biology. 2005. Vol. 15(11). P. 412-413.

23. Chan D., Woollacott M. Effects of level of meditation experience on attentional focus: is the efficiency of executive or orientation networks improved? // Journal of Alternative Complementary Medicine. 2007. Vol. 13(6). P. 651-657.

24. Desimone R., Duncan J. Neural mechanisms of selective visual attention // Annual Review of Neuroscience, 1995. Vol. 18. P. 193-222.

25. Elliott J.C., Wallace B.A., Giesbrecht B. A week-long meditation retreat decouples behavioral measures of the alerting and executive attention networks // Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. 2014. Vol. 17(8). P. 69.

26. Falikman M., Stepanov V. Chunking in rapid serial visual presentation: Consequences for visual awareness // Neuroscience and cognition: Consciousness and cognitive control. Abstracts. - Brussels: Flemish Academy of Sciences, 2012. P. 33-34.

27. Fan J., McCandliss B.D., Sommer T., Raz A., Posner M.I. Testing the efficiency and independence of attentional networks // Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. 2002. Vol. 14(3). P. 340-347.

28. Fernandez-Duque D., Johnson M.L. Cause and Effect theories of attention: The role of conceptual metaphors // Review of General Psychology. 2002. Vol. 6(2). P. 153-165.

29. Hodgins H.S., Adair K.C. Attentional processes and meditation // Consciousness and Cognition. 2010. Vol. 19(4). P. 872-878.

30. Holzel B.K., Carmody J., Vangel M., Congleton C., Yerramsetti S.M., Gard T., Lazar S.W. Mindfulness practice leads to increases in regional brain gray matter density // Psychiatry Research. 2011. Vol. 191(1). P. 36-43.

31. James W. Principles of Psychology. - N. Y.: Henry Holt, 1890. Vol. 1.

32. Josipovic Z., Dinstein I., Weber J., Heeger D.J. Influence of meditation on anti-correlated networks in the brain // Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. 2012. Vol. 5. P. 183.

33. Kahneman D. Attention and effort. - N. J.: Prentice Hall, 1973. Kanwisher, Wojciulik 2000 - Kanwisher N.G., Wojciulik E. Visual attention: Insights from brain imaging // Nature Reviews Neuroscience. 2000. Vol. 1(2). P. 91-100.

34. Koch C., Ullman S. Shifts in selective visual attention: Towards the underlying neural circuitry // Human Neurobiology. 1985. Vol. 4(4). P. 219-227.

35. Lazar S.W., Kerr C.E., Wasserman R.H., Gray J.R., Greve D.N., Treadway M.T., McGarvey M., Quinn B.T., Dusek J.A., Benson H., Rauch S.L., Moore C.I., Fischl B. Meditation experience is associated with increased cortical thickness // Neuroreport. 2005. Vol. 16(17). P. 1893-1897.

36. MacLean K.A., Ferrer E., Aichele S.R., Bridwell D.A., Zanesco A.P., Jacobs T.L., King B.G., Rosenberg E.L., Sahdra B.K., Shaver P.R., Wallace B.A., Mangun G.R., Saron C.D. Intensive meditation training improves perceptual discrimination and sustained attention // Psychological Science. 2010. Vol. 21(6). P. 829-839.

37. Moore A., Malinowski P. Meditation, mindfulness and cognitive flexibility // Consciousness and Cognition. 2009. Vol. 18(1). P. 176-186.

38. Pashler H. The Psychology of Attention. - Cambridge (MA): MIT Press, 1998.

39. Posner M.I., Petersen S.E. The attentional system of the human brain // Annual Review of Neuroscience. 1990. Vol. 13. P. 25-42.

40. Potter M.C., Nieuwenstein M., Strohminger N. Whole report versus partial report in RSVP sentences // Journal of Memory and Language. 2008. Vol. 58(4). P. 907-915.

41. Raymond J.E., Shapiro K.L., Arnell K.M. Temporary suppression of visual processing in an RSVP task: An attentional blink? // Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance. 1992. Vol. 18(3). P. 849-860.

42. Slagter H.A., Lutz A., Greischar L.L., Francis A.D., Nieuwenhuis S., Davis J.M., Davidson R.J. Mental training affects distribution of limited brain resources // PLoS Biology. 2007. Vol. 5(6). P. 138.

43. Tsai M.H., Chou W.L. Attentional orienting and executive control are affected by different types of meditation practice // Consciousness and Cognition. 2016. Vol. 46. P. 110-126.

44. Uttal W. The New Phrenology: The Limits of Localizing Cognitive Processes in the Brain. - Cambridge (MA): MIT Press, 2001.

45. Van Dam N.T., van Vugt M.K., Vago D.R., Schmalzl L., Saron C.D., Olendzki A., Meissner T., Lazar S.W., Kerr C.E., Gorchov J., Fox K.C.R., Field B.A., Britton W.B., Brefczynski-Lewis J.A., Meyer D.E. Mind the hype: A critical evaluation and prescriptive agenda for research on mindfulness and meditation // Perspective in Psychological Science. 2018. Vol. 13(1). P. 36-61.

46. van Vugt M.K., van den Hurk P.M. Modeling the effects of attentional cueing on meditators // Mindfulness. 2017. Vol. 8(1). P. 38-45.

47. Wahbeh H., Sagher A., Back W., Pundhir P., Travis F. A systematic review of transcendent states across meditation and contemplative traditions // Explore. 2018. Vol. 14(1). P. 19-35. Wallace 1970 - Wallace R.K. Physiological effects of transcendental meditation // Science. 1970. Vol. 167(3926). P. 1751-1754.