L.N. Tolstoy: The Enlightener who Overcame the Enlightenment

The article considers L.N. Tolstoy not only as a thinker who represents but also accomplishes Enlightenment. Through a comparison of his ideas with philosophy of Spinoza and Diderot, the author clarifies the aspects of the transition from Enlightenment to the unique Tolstoy’s religious and philosophical doctrine. A special attention is paid to the way of thinking, the relation to science and the specifics of the worldview of Tolstoy and Diderot. The contradiction between the way of thinking and the way of life of the three philosophers is revealed. The author also researches their philosophical interpretations of the nature of creative thought. Diderot describes the nature through the concept of paradoxism, Spinoza describes it with the concept of integrity, and Tolstoy uses the method of cohesion that he founds in literary works. If for the philosophers of European Enlightenment, the way of thinking is directly related to human nature, which is presented as a unity of natura naturans and natura naturata, then Tolstoy considers that the most important is a certain a priori sense of life, which is imbued with faith in God and with an instinct of self-giving that is love for the Supreme and other people. The method of cohesion leads Tolstoy away from the direct continuation of educational ideas, stressing the significance of appealing not only to reason but also to creative intuition. Tolstoy gradually moves away from rational perception of Life to its religious and existential foundations. Tolstoy’s worldview undergoes transition from the idea of a natural man to the idea of a human being who lives by commandments of Christ. Starting from the worldview of Enlightenment, Tolstoy comes to the creation of religious and philosophical doctrine, which is relevant to early 20th century.

Tolstoy, Spinoza, Diderot, Enlightenment, Enlightener, religious consciousness, worldview, mode of thought

1. Asmus V.F. (1957) L.N. Tolstoy’s Religious-Philosophical Treatises. In: Tolstoy L.N. The Complete Collected Works in 90 Volumes (vol. 23). Moscow: Khudozhestvennaya literatura (in Russian).

2. Asmus V.F. (1971) Dialectics of Necessity and Freedom in Spinoza’s Works. In: Asmus V.F. Selected Philosophical Works (vol. 2). Moscow: Moscow State University Pub. (in Russian).

3. Berlin I. (1960) Tolstoy and Enlightenment (Russian translation: Moscow: NLO, 2001).

4. Bozovic M. (2018) Tolstoy and Diderot on Women as “Dangerous Objects”. In: Cicovacki P. & Grek H.N. (Eds.) Tolstoy and Spirituality. Bos¬ton: Academic Studies Press.

5. Diderot D. (1986) Selected Works. Moscow: Mysl’, 1986 (Russian translation).

6. Dlugach T. (1975) Denis Diderot. Moscow: Mysl’, 1975 (in Russian).

7. Eikhenbaum B.M. (2009) Leo Tolstoy: Researches. Articles. Saint Pe-tersburg: Saint Petersburg State University Pub. (in Russian)

8. Israel J.I. (2001) Radical Enlightenment. Philosophy and the Making of Modernity 1650-1750. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

9. Klimova S. (2013) The Theorems of Reason and the Axioms of Faith. Spinoza and Tolstoy. Voprosy filosofii. 2013. No. 6, pp. 71-81 (in Russian).

10. Tolstoy L. N. & Strakhov N. N. (2003) Complete Collection of Corre-spondence in Two Volumes. Moscow (in Russian).

11. Lungina D. (2009) Modernity in the Diaries of S0ren Kierkegaard and Leo Tolstoy. Logos. 2009. No. 4-5, pp. 43-53 (in Russian).

12. Men’ A. (1995) Deserts of the Great Heresiarch. Religious-Philo¬sophical Views by L. N. Tolstoy. Vyshgorod. 1995. No. 5-6, pp.108-116 (in Russian)

13. Paperno I. (2014) “Who, What Am I?”: Tolstoy Struggles to Narrate the Self. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press (Russian translation: Moscow: NLO, 2018).

14. Schultz S.A. (2013) Traditions of D. Diderot and Gothic Novel in Leo Tolstoy’s Novel “Father Sergius”. Russkaya literatura. 2013. No. 1, pp. 111-130 (in Russian).

15. Spinoza B. (1957) Selected Works in 2 Volumes. Moscow: Nauka (Russian translation).

16. Tolstoy L.N. (1928-1958) Complete Collected Works in 90 Volumes. Moscow: Khudozhestvennaya literatura (in Russian).