Pyotr Chaadaev’s Journey to Italy. Part Two: Rome - Venice (1825)

The article continues the study of the circumstances of the journey of the Russian philosopher Pyotr Yakovlevich Chaadaev (1793-1856) in Italy in 1824-1825. This time we examine the stay of Chaadaev in Rome (March -April 1825) and Venice (late May - early June 1825). A special attention is paid to Chaadaev’s intensive communication during the Holy week in papal Rome with two outstanding Russian intellectuals: the major theorist of Russian liberalism, historian and economist Nikolai Ivanovich Turgenev (1789-1871) and the hero of the anti-Napoleonic wars, future prominent Decembrist Mikhail Fotievich Mitkov (1791-1849). The author believes that the personal experiences of Rome and meaningful creative debate with also prone to philosophizing Turgenev and Mitkov helped Chaadaev to develop main theoretical positions regarding the fate of the Catholic world. The author investigates the influence of “Roman meetings” with talented Russian artists and sculptors - Sylvester Shchedrin, Fyodor Bruni, Samuel Galberg. Based on the analysis of new sources, the author disputes the established conclusions in the literature about the circumstances of Chaadaev’s stay in Venice. The article also analyzes the circumstances of Chaadayev’s return to Russia in 1826, in the midst of the investigation of the “Decembrist conspiracy,” as well as the dramatic fate of Mitkov and Turgenev, his friends during the “Roman walks.” The article concludes that in Russian philosophy and culture Pyotr Chaadaev was the founder of research into the fruitful “Coliseum topic” on the ratio between the ancient and Christian traditions in European culture.

1. Chaadaev P.Y. (1991) Complete Works and Selected Letters in 2 Vols. (Z.A. Kamensky, Ed.). Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

2. Gershenzon M.O. (2010) P.Y. Chaadaev. Life and Thinking. In: Gershenzon M.O. Selected Works in 2 Parts (part 2, pp. 180-301). Moscow: ROSSPEN (in Russian).

3. Kara-Murza A.A. (2012a) How Ideas Turn into Ideologies: Russian Context. The Philosophy Journal. 2012. No. 2, pp. 27-44 (in Russian).

4. Kara-Murza A.A. (2012b) Sylvester Feodosevich Shchedrin. In: Kara-Murza A.A. Famous Russians in Amalfi (pp. 21-37). Moscow: Altex (in Russian).

5. Kara-Murza A.A. (2014) Famous Russians about Rome. Moscow: Olga Morozova Publishing (in Russian).

6. Kara-Murza A.A. (2016a) Pyotr Yakovlevich Chaadaev. In: Kara-Murza A.A. Famous Russians about Florence (pp. 117-125). Moscow: Olga Morozova Publishing (in Russian).

7. Kara-Murza A.A. (2016b The Philosophical Dilemmas of “Letters of a Russian Traveler” of N.M. Karamzin. Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences = Filosofskie nauki. 2016. No. 11, pp. 55-68 (in Russian).

8. Kara-Murza A.A. (2016c) Swiss travels of Nikolai Karamzin. 1789-1790. Moscow: Aquilon (in Russian).

9. Kara-Murza A.A. (2017) Traveler or Fugitive? A New Reading of Nikolai Karamzin’s Letters of a Russian Traveler. Russian Studies in Philosophy. Vol. 55, no. 6. pp. 410-421.

10. Kara-Murza A.A. (2018) Spiritual Rebirth: Ivan Turgenev’s 1840 Trip to Rome. Russian Studies in Philosophy. Vol. 56, no. 5, pp. 434-443.

11. Mandelstam O. (1998) Pyotr Chaadaev. In: Ermichev A.A. & Zlatopolskaya A.A. (Eds.) P.Y. Chaadaev: Pro et Contra (pp. 401-406). St. Petersburg: RKhGI (in Russian).

12. Pogodin M.P. (1844) Year in Foreign Lands (1839). Travel Diary. Moscow: Stepanov Publishing (in Russian).

13. Rozanov V.V. (1994a) Rome. Easter in St. Peter’s Cathedral. In: V.V. Rozanov. Another Land, Another Sky... Complete Collection of Travel Essays of 1899-1913 (pp. 100-105). Moscow: Tanais (in Russian).

14. Rozanov V.V. (1994b) Rome. Good Friday in the Cathedral of St. Peter. In: Rozanov V.V. Another Land, Another Sky. Complete Collection of Travel Essays of1899-1913 (pp. 85-88). Moscow: Tanais (in Russian).

15. Rozanov V.V. (1998) Chaadaev and Prince Odoyevsky. In: Ermichev A.A. & Zlatopolskaya A.A. (Eds.) P.Y. Chaadaev: Pro et Contra (pp. 360-369). Saint Petersburg: RKhGI (in Russian).

16. Shakhovskoy D.I. (1935) P. Y. Chaadaev on the Way to Russia in 1826. Literaturnoye nasledstvo. Vol. 19-21, pp. 16-32 (in Russian).

17. Shchedrin S.F. (2014) Italian letters and reports of Sylvester Feodosievich Shchedrin. 1818-1830. Moscow: Alyans-Arkheo (in Russian).

18. Tarasov B.N. (2017) Chaadaev. Life. Personality. Creativity. In: Tarasov B.N. Selected Works in 4 Vols. (Vol. 1, pp.109-513). St. Petersburg: Aletheia (in Russian).

19. Turgenev N.I. (1913) Diaries of Nikolay Ivanovich Turgenev. 1811-1816 (E.I. Tarasov, Ed.). Saint Petersburg: Imperial Academy of Sciences Press (in Russian).

20. Turgenev N.I. (1936) Decembrist N.I. Turgenev. Letter to Brother S.I. Turgenev. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences Press (in Russian).

21. Turgenev N.I. (2017) Diaries and Letters of Nikolai Ivanovich Turgenev. Vol. 4: Journey to Western Europe. 1824-1825 (M.Y. Korenev, Ed.). Saint Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriya (in Russian).

22. Zhukova O.A. (2011) Spiritual Experience and Culture of Mind: Religious and Philosophical Tradition in University Education. Kul’turologicheskiy zhurnal. 2011. No. 1 (in Russian).