The Philosophy of War in the Works of French Scholars

The article discusses the formation and development of the philosophy of war in the works of French scholars from the 19th century until present times. The emergence of the philosophy of war was a natural event in the development of views on war set forth in the works of ancient philosophers as well as by thinkers, political and religious figures of the European Middle Ages. In France, the emergence of this philosophical trend, which was an organic part of the philosophy of politics, was associated with the artillery general Marquis Georges de Chambray, a veteran of the Napoleonic Wars. It was he who introduced the term “philosophy of war” into scientific use. This name was soon accepted, not only in the French philosophical environment, but throughout Europe. At the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries, there appeared an entire galaxy of French authors who closely studied the phenomenon of war from the standpoint of philosophy. These included P.-J. Proudhon, R. Henry, J. Lagorgette, G. Lagneau, E. Lavisse, C. Letourneau, A. Rambaud and others. They contributed to the formation of the philosophy of war in French philosophical and political thought. The First and Second World Wars discovered new names in the French philosophy of war: Teilhard de Chardin, A. Bergson, M. Proust, J.-P. Sartre, R. Aron, C. de Gaulle, G. Boutoul and others. A later generation of “philosophers of war” successfully developed the already established trend in philosophy. Thus, A. Philonenko continued the tradition in his Essay on the Philosophy of War. French authors are very interested in the works of the Prussian philosopher of war C. von Clausewitz. Considering his views, R. Aron and R. Girard wrote works discussing the place of war in social life. In the 21st century, the problem of wars and military conflicts has not lost its relevance. The author concludes that French philosophy of war meets modern challenges. Its current representatives, such as J.-B. Jeangene Vilmer, J.-P. Dupuy and others, confirm the vitality and relevance of this trend.

1. Aron R. (1951) Les Guerres en chaîne. Paris: Gallimard (in French).

2. Aron R. (1962) Paix et guerre entre les nations. Paris: Calmann-Levy (in French).

3. Aron R. (1976) Penser la guerre, Clausewitz. Paris: Gallimard (in French).

4. Bouthoul G. (1951) Les guerres. Elements de polemologie. Paris: Payot (in French).

5. Bouthoul G. (1962) Le phenomene-guerre. Paris: Payot (in French).

6. Cazier J.-Ph. (2015) Henri Bergson. In: Les philosophes et la guerre de 1914–1918 (p. 10). Bruxelles: Sils Maria (in French).

7. Chambray G. (1829) Philosophie de la guerre (2nd ed.). Paris: Pillet aîné (in French).

8. Danilenko I.S. (2006) All Known, but Always Unfamiliar. In: Science and War (pp. 204–237). Moscow: People’s Pushkin Fund (in Russian).

9. De Gaulle C. (1932) Le fil de l’épée. Paris: Berger-Levrault (in French).

10. De Gaulle C. (1938) La France et son armée. Paris: Plon (in French).

11. Dupuy J.-P. (2019) La guerre qui ne peut pas avoir lieu : Essai de métaphysique nucléaire. – Paris: Desclée De Brouwer (in French).

12. Duroselle J.-B. (1962) Paix et guerre entre les nations : la théorie des relations internationales selon Raymond Aron. Revue française de science politique. Vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 963–979 (in French).

13. Girard R. (2007) Ahever Clausewitz : entretiens avec. Paris: Benoît Chantre (in French).

14. Glucksmann A. (1967) Discours de la guerre, théorie et stratégie. Paris: L’Herne (in French).

15. Henry R. (1879) Essai d’un abrégé de la philosophie de la guerre… Paris: Librairie militaire de J. Dumaine (in French).

16. Huygue F.-B. (2007) Polémologie: forces et signes. In: Héritage et actualité de la polémologie. Paris: Téraèdre (in French).

17. Jeangène Vilmer J.-B. (2012) La guerre au nom de l’humanité. Paris: PUF (in French).

18. Lagneau G. (1892) Les conséquences des guerres. Séances et travaux de l’Académie des sciences morales et politiques. Vol. 38 (in French).

19. Lagorgette J. (1906) Le rôle de la guerre. Paris: Giard et Brière (in French).

20. Landsberg P.-L. (1939) Réflexion sur une philosophie de la guerre et de la paix. Esprit. Vol. 8, no. 85, pp. 10–22 (in French).

21. Lavisse E. (1899) Le programme du cours. In: L’armée à travers les ages : Conférences faites en 1898 à l’Ecole spéciale militaire de Saint-Cyr. Paris: Chapelot (in French).

22. Letourneau C. (1895) La guerre dans les diverses races humaines. Paris: L. Bataille (in French).

23. Loir M.-E. (1906) Étude d’un cas concret de la guerre russo-japonaise. Paris: Charles Lavauzelle (in French).

24. Odysse-Barrot F. (1864) Lettres sur la philosophie de l’histoire. Paris. Germer Bailliere (in French).

25. Olivier E. (1910) Philosophie d’une guerre: 1870. Paris: Flammarion (in French).

26. Philonenko A. (1976) Essai sur la philosophie de la guerre (2nd ed.). Paris: J. Vrin (in French).

27. Proudhon P.-J. (1861) La Guerre et la Paix. Paris: Michel-Lévy frères (Russian translation: A. Cherenin, 1864).

28. Rambaud A. (1902) L’émir Abd-el-Kader. In: L’armée à travers les ages: Conférences faites en 1900 à l’Ecole spéciale militaire de Saint-Cyr. Paris: Chapelot (in French).

29. Sartre J.-P. (1983) Carnets de la drôle de guerre. Paris: Gallimard (Russian translation retrieved from http://www.fedy-diary.ru/html/092012/19092012-02a.html).

30. Secăreş V. (1975) Sociologia războiului şi sociologia armatei. In: Sociologia militară (Vol. 1). Bucureşti: Editura militară (in Romanian).

31. Soloviev A.V. (2010) Theoretical Research of the Phenomenon of War in Russian and France in the 20th Century. Bulletin of Lomonosov Moscow State University. Series 12: Political Sciences. 2010. No. 6, pp. 80–81 (in Russian).

32. Soloviev A.V. (2018) A.E. Snesarev ia a Representative of the RussianPhilosophy of War. Filosofiya i obshchestvo. 2018. No. 3, pp. 100–115 (in Russian).

33. Steinmetz S.R. (1907) Die Philozophie des Krieges. Leipzig: J.A. Barth (in German).

34. Teilhard de Chardin P. (1965) Écrits du temps de la guerre (1916–1919). Paris: Grasset (in French)