Preview

Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences

Advanced search

Hybrid Warfare: Politico-Military Pankration of the 21st Century

https://doi.org/10.30727/0235-1188-2021-64-6-55-73

Abstract

 The article is devoted to the phenomenon of interstate confrontation known as “hybrid war.” It attempts to consider this phenomenon in relation to pankration, the ancient Greek martial art with minimum limitations. The paper defines the philosophical and historical preconditions for hybrid war, its epistemological and ideological aspects. The author assesses the statement declaring Russia guilty of waging this type of war. Analysis of relevant sources allows us to answer the question of the theoretical prerequisites for the formation of the concept of hybrid wars and to name the authors who first expressed ideas of the transformation of war into a new type of military confrontation. An attempt is made to perform a comparative analysis of various interpretations of the concept of “hybrid war.” The place of this concept among others that are related to the so-called “new wars” is considered. The author questions a negative connotation to the concept of hybrid war and the legitimacy of attempts by Western countries to attribute the conduct of this type of military action exclusively to Russia. A number of countries attempt to use Russia as a “scapegoat,” and this complex has been described by the French philosopher R. Girard. A broader interpretation of this mechanism leads to sacralization of collective aggression, but not in relation to an individual but in relation to a participant in international relations. Comprehension of the essential features of hybrid war, of its tendencies towards eliminating restrictions and regulating forms and methods of achieving military and political goals makes it possible to identify the possibilities of resisting aggressive aspirations of some countries trying to impose their scenarios for resolving international contradictions on other states.

About the Author

Alexey V. Soloviev
Lomonosov Moscow State University
Russian Federation

Alexey V. Soloviev – Ph.D. in Philosophy, Associate Professor of the Department of the Philosophy of Politics and Law, Faculty of Philosophy, Lomonosov Moscow State University.

Moscow



References

1. Aron R. (1969) Les Désillusions du progress. Paris: Calmann-Levy (in French).

2. Belozerov V.K. (2014) Controlled Chaos and Global Political Strategies. Geopolitika i bezopasnost’. No. 4, pp. 9−13 (in Russian).

3. Belozerov V.K. & Soloviev A.V. (2015) Hybrid War in the Domestic Political and Scientific Discourse. Vlast’. No. 9, pp. 8−9 (in Russian).

4. Brossollet G. (1975) Essai sur la non-bataille. Paris: Belin (in French).

5. Carrère R. (1969) La guerre, cette inconnue. Guerre et paix. No. 1, pp. 19−22 (in French).

6. Delbrück H. (2003) History of the Art of War. The Ancient World. The Germans. Smolensk: Rusich (Russian translation).

7. Domnin I. & Savinkin A. (2005) Asymmetric Warfare. Otechestvennye Zapiski. No. 5 (26), pp. 66−72 (in Russian).

8. Girard R. (2010) The Scapegoat. Saint Petersburg: Ivan Limbakh Publishing House (Russian translation).

9. Girard R. (2018) I See Satan Falling Like Lightning. Moscow: BBI publishing house (Russian translation).

10. Henrotin J. (2014) Techno-guérilla et guerre hybride. Le pire des deux mondes. Paris: Nuvis (in French).

11. Huntington S. (1994) The Clash of Civilizations? Polis. No. 1, pp. 33−48 (Russian translation).

12. Kaldor M. (2015) New and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era. Moscow: Gaidar Institute Press (Russian translation).

13. Komleva N.A. (2017) Hybrid Warfare: Its Essence and Specificity. Tempus et memoria. Vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 128−137 (in Russian).

14. Kudors A. (2015) Hybrid War – A New Security Challenge for Europe. Background Notes of Latvian Presidency of the Council of the European Union.

15. Kuznetsov D.V. (Comp.) (2018) National Military Strategies of the USA. n.p. (in Russian).

16. Lebedev A.V. (Comp.) (1989) Fragments of early Greek Philosophers. Part 1. From Epic Theocosmogonies to the Emergence of Atomism. Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

17. Panarin A.S. (2004) Strategic Instability in the 21st Century. Moscow: Algoritm (in Russian).

18. Panarin A.S. (2014) Orthodox Civilization. Moscow: Institute of Russian Civilization Publisher (in Russian).

19. Schmitt C. (2007) The Theory of the Partisan. Moscow: Praxis (Russian translation).

20. Soloviev A.V. (2015) Civilization and War. In: Moshelkov E.N., Boitsova O.Yu., & Rastorguev V.N. (Eds.) Philosophy of Politics and Law: Yearbook of Research Papers. Volume 6: Civilizations in the Era of Globalism (pp. 52−62). Moscow: A.V. Vorobiev Publishing (in Russian).

21. Sun Tzu (2003) Treatises on the Art of War. Moscow (Russian translation).

22. Tardieu A. (1921) La Paix. Préface de Clémenceau. Paris: Payot & Cie (in French).

23. van Creveld M. (2015) The Transformation of War. Moscow: IRISEN (Russian translation).

24. von Clausewitz C. (1997) On War. Moscow (Russian translation).

25. Wallerstein I. (2003) After Liberalism. Moscow: URSS (Russian translation).

26. Welschinger H. (Comp.) (1917) Les dévastations allemandes dans les départements envahis, mars-avril 1917. Paris: Librairie Militaire Berger-Levrault (in French).


Review

For citations:


Soloviev A.V. Hybrid Warfare: Politico-Military Pankration of the 21st Century. Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences. 2021;64(6):56-73. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.30727/0235-1188-2021-64-6-55-73



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 0235-1188 (Print)
ISSN 2618-8961 (Online)