Temptation of Ethics and Trial of Conscience: Features of Russian Moral Philosophy

The article discusses the criteria for authentic humanity within the moral paradigm of Russian philosophy. In Russian philosophy, the disciplines of ethics and anthropology are intertwined, as the question of human nature is primarily addressed from a moral perspective. The article primarily focuses on the interplay between faith and conscience, a topic that is approached and resolved differently within the context of Russian philosophy compared to Western European philosophy. For instance, the concept of “elimination of the ethical,” a fundamental aspect of S. Kierkegaard’s existential philosophy, is discussed. The transcendence of ethical rationalism through a leap of faith, exemplified by Abraham’s act, forms the essence of authentic Christian ethics. It explores how faith is challenged by ethics, which requires not blind faith, but rational behavior in accordance with the widely accepted norms of social morality. The article highlights the conflict between existential faith and social ethics as the primary contradiction identified by S. Kierkegaard. The author revisits the ideas of F.M. Dostoevsky, N.A. Berdyaev, and others to illustrate that within the context of Russian philosophy, the critical situation is less about the anticipation of death and more about the moral anguish of conscience arising from the evil and falsehood prevalent in the world, a sentiment shared by diverse individuals like V.S. Solovyov and V.M. Shukshin. This perspective significantly redefines the concept of the existential in Russian philosophy, equating it with profound moral reflection. In discussing philosophical and anthropological issues under the “post-human threat,” the author introduces the concept of “conscientious faith.” This concept, serving as a fundamental anthropological unit, posits that it is the conscience, with its appeal to personal moral responsibility, that reveals the moral essence of an individual, thereby establishing human uniqueness.

1. Berdyaev N.A. (1993) On the Purpose of Man. Moscow: Respublika (in Russian).

2. Bulgakov S.N. (1993) Ivan Karamazov as a Philosophical Type. In: Bulgakov S.N. Collected Works (Vol. 2, pp. 3–15). Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

3. Dostoevsky F.M. (1987) On Russian Literature. Moscow: Sovremennik (in Russian).

4. Foucault M. (1994) The Order of Things: An Archaeology of the Human Sciences. Saint Petersburg: A-cad (Russian translation).

5. Gaydenko P.P. (1993) The Mystical Revolutionism of N.A. Berdyaev. In: Berdyaev N.A. On the Purpose of Man (pp. 5–20). Moscow: Respublika (in Russian).

6. Girenok F.I. (2021) Introduction to Singular Philosophy. Moscow: Prospekt (in Russian).

7. Ivanov V.I. (1990) Dostoevsky and the Novel-Tragedy. In: Borisov V.M. & Roginsky A.B. (Comps.) On Dostoevsky. The Works of Dostoevsky in Russian Thought, 1881–1931 (pp. 164–192). Moscow: Kniga (in Russian).

8. Kierkegaard S. (1993) Fear and Trembling. Moscow: Respublika (Russian translation).

9. Levitsky S.A. (2008) Tragedy of Freedom: Selected Works. Moscow: Astrel’ (in Russian).

10. Odoevsky V.F. (1981) Russian Nights. In: Odoevsky V.F. Collected Works (Vol. 1, pp. 31–249). Moscow: Khudozhestvennaya Literatura (in Russian).

11. Pomerantz G. (2013) Openness to the Abyss: Encounters with Dostoevsky. Saint Petersburg: Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ (in Russian).

12. Schaeffer J.-M. (2010) The End of Human Exceptionalism. Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie (Russian translation).

13. Shestov L. (1992) Kierkegaard and Existential Philosophy (The Voice Crying in the Wilderness). Moscow: Progress – Gnosis (in Russian).

14. Sviridov G. (2002) Music as Destiny. Moscow: Molodaya Gvardiya (in Russian).

15. Soina O.S. (1995) The Phenomenon of Russian Moralizing: Ethical Essays. Novosibirsk: Nauka (in Russian).

16. Varava V.V. (2013) Ethics and Moral Philosophy (Some Features of Russian Philosophy). In: Maslin M.A. (Comp.) Russian Philosophical Thought: In Russia, in Russia, and Abroad: A Collection of Scientific Articles, Dedicated to the 70th Anniversary of the Department of Russian Philosophy (pp. 72–82). Moscow: Moscow University Press (in Russian).

17. Varava V.V. (2022) “Oh, How Much Suffering in Faith!” (The Relationship between Faith and Conscience in Russian Philosophy). Russkaya filosofiya. No. 1, pp. 40–56 (in Russian).

18. Zenkovsky V.V. (2001) History of Russian Philosophy. Moscow: Akademicheskiy Proekt, Raritet (in Russian).