The Intellectual Legacy of the Gordin Brothers in Emigration: Philosophical Anthropology and Social Philosophy

The article presents the findings of a historical-philosophical analysis of the Gordin brothers’ works during their period of emigration. This is the first study in Russian historiography dedicated to the conceptual legacy of these two thinkers following their forced departure from the USSR. The authors draw attention to the fact that the biography of the Gordin brothers continues to evoke numerous questions within the scholarly community, and their years in the USA remains under-researched not only by Russian scholars but also by their international counterparts. The article primarily examines philosophical-anthropological and social-philosophical issues. It is demonstrated that both W.L. Gordin and A.L. Gordin remained true to their spiritual bearings in emigration. W.L. Gordin continued his investigations in the field of the philosophy of technology and ontology, whereas A.L. Gordin sustained his work on a doctrine he termed “interindividualism.” The authors identify both similarities and differences in the intellectual explorations of the Gordin brothers. Special emphasis is placed on exploring how philosophical individualism influenced the intellectual pursuits of the thinkers, and how this manifested both in philosophical anthropology and social philosophy. Furthermore, their attitudes towards religion (especially Judaism), contemporary political doctrines (particularly Marxism), and scientific progress (especially quantum theory) are investigated. In emigration, W.L. Gordin remained an atheist, while his brother, conversely, developed a personal understanding of God, with whom the Ego engages in ongoing dialogue. In conclusion, it is posited that while the works of A.L. Gordin (in their conceptual content) align closely with the philosophical treatises of M. Buber (as well as the works of other philosophers inspired by Judaism), the writings of W.L. Gordin to some extent anticipated early transhumanism.

1. Arolovich A.B. (2015) Anarchism-Universalism in the Context of the Russian “Cosmic Paradigm” of the Beginning of the 20th Century (dissertation). Moscow: Moscow State University (in Russian).

2. Avrich P. (2006) Russian Anarchists: 1905–1917 (I.E. Polotsk, Trans.). Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf (Russian translation).

3. Beoby W. (1932) The Task of Man. The Clarion. Vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 14–15.

4. Beoby W. (1933) World-Invention. The Clarion. Vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 9–11.

5. Beoby W. (1934) Du chaos à l’univeselle invention. L’en dehors. No. 270, pp. 110–111 (in French).

6. Beoby W. (1935a) L’individu. L’en dehors. No. 279, pp. 247–248 (in French).

7. Beoby W. (1935b) Qu’est-ce que la societe? L’en dehors. No. 270, pp. 284–285 (In French).

8. Garyavin A.N. (2004) A.L. and W.L. Gordin’s State and Civil Law Ideas in the Light of the Theory of Anarchism-Universalism (Pananarchism). In: Institute of Law and Entrepreneurship – 10 Years: Jubilee Collection of Works (pp. 53–64). Saint Petersburg: Institute of Law and Entrepreneurship (in Russian).

9. Gerasimov N. & Tkachenko D. (2021) From Pan-Anarchism to Social Engineering and Interindividualism: The Human Being Problem in the Work of the Gordin Brothers. Istoriya filosofii. Vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 99–109 (in Russian).

10. Gerasimov N. (2023) Who Are the Gordin Brothers? (Based on Archival Documents of the Yiddish Research Institute in New York). Otechestvennaya filosofiya. Vol. 1, no.1, pp. 77–88 (in Russian).

11. Gordin A.L. (1921a) Anarcho-Universalism. I. Classes and Types. Cherez sotsializm k anarkho-universalizmu. No. 1, pp. 7–27 (in Russian).

12. Gordin A.L. (1921b) Anarcho-Universalism. II. Inter-Individualism. Nation and Personality. Cherez sotsializm k anarkho-universalizmu. No. 2, pp. 7–38 (in Russian).

13. Gordin A.L. (1921c) Inter-Individualism in Culture. II. Follower and Forerunner. Cherez sotsializm k anarkho-universalizmu. No. 2, pp. 50–64 (in Russian).

14. Gordin A.L. (1921d) Anarkho-Universalism. II. Inter-Individualism. Cherez sotsializm k anarkho-universalizmu. No. 3, pp. 8–53 (in Russian).

15. Gordin A.L. (1921e) Anarcho-Universalism. III. Transformism. Cherez sotsializm k anarkho-universalizmu. No. 5, pp. 1–21 (in Russian).

16. Gordin A.L. (1922) Inter-Individualism. Moscow: A(narkhisty) U(niversalisty) I(nterindividualisty) (in Russian).

17. Gordin A. (1932a) The Ideology of the Organaziers. The Clarion. Vol. 1, no. 1. pp. 7–9.

18. Gordin A. (1932b) Class Struggle. The Clarion. Vol. 1, no. 2. pp. 5–8.

19. Gordin A. (1932c) Social Mythology. The Clarion. Vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 3–6.

20. Gordin A. (1940) Communism Unmasked. New York: I.N. Nord Publisher.

21. Gordin W. (1926) The Philosophy of Relativity. The Journal of Philosophy. Vol. 23, no. 19, pp. 517–524.

22. Goncharok M. (2017) Ashes of Our Bonfires. Essays on the History of the Jewish Anarchist Movement (Yiddish Anarchism). Moscow: Common Place (in Russian).

23. Katsis L.F (2020) The Judaic Theologem of the Russian Avant-Garde (Vladimir Mayakovsky, Velimir Khlebnikov, Abba Gordin and Velvl Gordin-Beoby against the Background of Musaf Kedushah on the New Year. Voprosy teologii. Vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 17–51 (in Russian).

24. Kuznetsov S.V. (2014) Linguistica Cosmica: The Birth of the Cosmic Paradigm. Sovremennaya nauka. No. 2, pp. 39–65 (in Russian).

25. Kuchinov E.V. (2019) The Technique of Anarchy: Utopias on the Fields of the Heidegger Question. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. No. 4, pp. 124–141 (in Russian).

26. Martynov M.Y. (2016) The Language of Russian Anarchism. Moscow: Kul’turnaya revolyutsiya (in Russian).

27. Rublev D.I. (2019) Russian Anarchism in the 20th Century. Moscow: Rodina (in Russian).

28. Türk L. (2014) Religiöser Nonkonformismus und Radikale Yidishkayt. Abba Gordin (1887–1964) und die Prozesse der Gemeinschaftsbildung in der jiddisch-anarchistischen Wochenschrift Fraye Arbeter Shtime 1937–1945 (doctoral thesis). Halle: Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg (in German).

29. Türk L. (2022) Zionism, Monotheism, and the Self: Abba Gordin’s Religioanarchist Reading of the Scriptures. Journal of Ecumenical Studies. Vol. 57, no. 1. pp. 58–76.

30. Udartsev S.F. (2019) A.L. Gordin: A Theorist of Post-Classical Anarchism of the 20th Century. In: Smykalin A.S. (Ed.) One Hundred Years of the Ural State Law University (1918–2018) (Vol. 1, pp. 826–841) Yekaterinburg: Ural State Law University (in Russian).