German Anti-Semitism in the Genesis of the Term “Humanism”

The article examines the transformation of the understanding of humanism from the Renaissance to the modern era, focusing on the mechanism of exclusion that defines the key framework of social action, including in the present day. This social mechanism pushes declared values beyond observable reality, generates cognitive paralysis, and ultimately points to the existence of an alternate reality that dominates a morally depleted society. The replacement of reality with constructs fabricated by various doctrinal groups is identified as a major delusion of our times, luring people into self-deception, seducing them with illusory values, and confusing the noble with the ignoble. The mechanisms of exclusion serve as the essential foundation for excluding thought, values, and ideals from everyday social life. This exclusion is evident in ancient democracy, which despised slaves; in Russian literature, which flirted with serfdom; and most notably in modern autocracy and liberalism, which focus solely on their own kind. The article takes as its starting point the transitional state of society where, under the conditions of the Reformation, Renaissance values understood as humanism are reduced to post-Renaissance “humanism.” From this perspective, the treatise of F.I. Niethammer is analyzed for its contribution to the modern understanding of humanism in contrast to the educational philanthropinism of J.B. Basedow. The article reveals the connection between the term “humanism” and German anti-Semitism, showing that humanism, as conceived in the German context, was intended for ethnic insiders and educationally stood as an antithesis to the Frankfurt Philanthropin, the largest German educational institution opened in a Jewish ghetto for children from poor families. The author concludes with historical parallels and findings that identify the characteristics of modern societies shaped by the discussed mechanism of exclusion.

1. Baudelaire C. (1997) Feux d’Artifice. In: Baudelaire C. Les fleurs du mal. Épaves. Spleen de Paris. Paradis artificiels. Essays, Diaries. Articles on Art (pp. 405–422). Moscow: Ripol Klassik (Russian translation).

2. Eby F. (1931) Introduction. In: Eby F. (Ed.) Early Protestant Educators (рр. 1–7). New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.

3. Galliner A. (1958) The Philanthropin in Frankfurt: Its Educational and Cultural Significance for German Jewry. The Leo Baeck Institute Year Book. Vol. 3, no 1. pp. 169–186.

4. Heidegger M. (1998) Introduction to Metaphysics. Saint-Petersburg: Vysshaya religiozno-filosofskaya shkola (Russian translation).

5. Heidegger M. (2016) Ponderings II–VI (Black Notebooks 1931–1938). Moscow: Gaidar Institute (Russian translation).

6. Heidegger M. (2018) Ponderings VII–XI (Black Notebooks 1938–1939). Moscow: Gaidar Institute (Russian translation).

7. Heidegger M. (2020) Ponderings XIΙ–XV (Black Notebooks 1939–1941). Moscow: Gaidar Institute (Russian translation).

8. Karpov A. (2021) Higher Education in Russia: Unrealizable Hopes? Voprosy filosofii. No. 1, pp. 5–16 (in Russian).

9. Luther M. (1970) An den christlichen Adel deutscher Nation von des christlichen Standes Besserung. In: Streller S. (Ed.) Hutten, Müntzer, Luther. Werke in zwei Bänden (Vol. 2, pp. 15–100). Berlin: Aufbau-Verlag (in German).

10. Mertz G. (1902) Das Schulwesen der Deutschen Reformation im 16. Jahrhundert. Heidelberg: C. Winter (in German).

11. Niethammer F.I. (1808) Der Streit des Philanthropinismus und Humanismus in der Theorie des Erziehungs-Unterrichts unsrer Zeit. Jena: F. Frommann (in German).

12. Rupp H.F. (1996) Philipp Melanchthon (1497–1560). Prospects: Quarterly Review of Comparative Education. Vol. 26, no. 3. pp. 611–621.

13. Schmidt K. (1880) The History of Pedagogy, Presented in the World-Historical Development and in Organic Connection with the Cultural Life of Peoples. Vol. 3: The History of Pedagogy from Luther to Pestalozzi. Moscow: K.T. Soldatenkov Publishing (Russian translation).

14. Tinsley B.S. (1989) Johann’s Sturm’s Method for Humanistic Pedagogy. Sixteenth Century Journal. Vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 23–40.