Mind and Brain: Experience in Developing Fundamental Theoretical Issues of the Hard Problem of Consciousness and Its Significance for Neuroscience

The article presents a retrospective analysis of the author’s 70-year contribution to philosophy and science, focusing primarily on the hard problem of consciousness – the relationship between mental phenomena and neurophysiological processes. The author traces his intellectual journey in addressing this fundamental challenge to natural scientific knowledge and presents his conceptual framework, initially developed in the early 1960s. The discussion examines the significant challenges faced in defending an information-based approach to consciousness, particularly during the notable debate with E.V. Ilyenkov and subsequent opposition from his followers who held considerable influence in philosophical circles. Despite ideological pressure and accusations of revisionism, the author successfully advanced his theoretical framework, publishing numerous books and articles that elaborate on his theoretical and methodological approaches to decoding neural correlates of subjective reality. Following the publication of an English-language article outlining his theoretical foundations in a leading international neuroscience journal in 2019, the author received extensive recognition, including invitations to keynote international conferences and join editorial boards of international journals. This response demonstrates the pressing need for theoretical and methodological developments in neuroscience and related disciplines, highlighting a deficit in fundamental theoretical frameworks capable of guiding and integrating empirical research. The article concludes by emphasizing the significance of the information paradigm and its derivative approaches for studying consciousness, mental processes, and genetic aspects of biological functions.

1. Dubinin N.P. (1980) Biological and Social Inheritance. Kommunist. No. 11, pp. 62–74 (in Russian).

2. Dubrovsky D.I. (1966) Physiological and Logical. Voprosy filosofii. No. 8 (in Russian).

3. Dubrovsky D.I. (1968) Brain and Psyche (On the Unjustified Philosophical Denial of the Psychophysiological Problem). Voprosy filosofii. No. 8, pp. 122–135 (in Russian).

4. Dubrovsky D.I. (1969) Regarding E.V. Ilyenkov’s Article “Psyche and Brain”. Voprosy filosofii. No. 3, pp. 142–146 (in Russian).

5. Dubrovsky D.I. (1971) Mental Phenomena and the Brain. Philosophical Analysis of the Psychophysiological Problem in Relation to Some Current Issues in Neurophysiology, Psychology, and Cybernetics. Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

6. Dubrovsky D.I. (1979) Decoding the Codes (Methodological Aspects of the Problem). Voprosy filosofii. No. 12, pp. 87–100 (in Russian).

7. Dubrovsky D.I. (1980) Information. Consciousness. Brain. Moscow: Vysshaya shkola (in Russian).

8. Dubrovsky D.I. (1983) The Problem of the Ideal. Subjective Reality. Moscow: Mysl’ (in Russian).

9. Dubrovsky D.I. (1988) The Problem of the Ideal: The Nature of Mind and Its Relationship to the Brain and Social Medium. Moscow: Progress Publishers.

10. Dubrovsky D.I. (Ed.) (1989) Deafblindness: Historical and Methodological Aspects. Myths and Reality. Moscow: Filosofskoe obshchestvo (in Russian).

11. Dubrovsky D.I. (2002) The Problem of the Ideal. Subjective Reality (2nd ed.). Moscow: Kanon+ (in Russian).

12. Dubrovsky D.I. (2015) The Problem of Mind and Brain: A Theoretical Solution. Moscow: Kanon+ (in Russian).

13. Dubrovsky D.I. (2017) The Problem of Free Will and Modern Neuroscience. Pavlov Journal of Higher Nervous Activity. Vol. 67, no. 6, pp. 739–754 (in Russian).

14. Dubrovsky D.I. (Ed.) (2018) Deafblindness: Historical and Methodological Aspects. Myths and Reality (2nd ed.). Moscow: Iintell (in Russian).

15. Dubrovsky D.I. (2019a) The Problem of Consciousness: Theory and Critique of Alternative Concepts. Moscow: Lenand (in Russian).

16. Dubrovsky D.I. (2019b) The Problem of Free Will and Modern Neuroscience. Neuroscience and Behavioral Physiology. Vol. 49, no. 5, pp. 629–639.

17. Dubrovsky D.I. (2019c) “The Hard Problem of Consciousness”: Theoretical Solution of its Main Questions. AIMS Neuroscience. Vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 85–103.

18. Dubrovsky D.I. (2021a) Mental Phenomena and the Brain. Philosophical Analysis of the Problem in Connection with Some Current Issues in Neurophysiology, Psychology, and Cybernetics (2nd ed.). Moscow: URSS (in Russian).

19. Dubrovsky D.I. (2021b) Information. Consciousness. Brain. Decoding the Brain Codes of Mental Phenomena (2nd ed.). Moscow: URSS (in Russian).

20. Dubrovsky D.I. (2023) The Problem of the Ideal. Subjective Reality (3rd ed.). Moscow: Lenand (in Russian).

21. Ilyenkov E.V. (1977) The Formation of Personality: To the Results of Scientific Experiment. Kommunist. No. 2, pp. 68–79 (in Russian).

22. Maidanskiy A.D. (Ed.) (2016) Ilyenkov Readings: Materials of the 18th International Scientific Conference, Belgorod, April 28–29, 2016. Belgorod: Belgorod Publishing (in Russian).

23. Margolis J. (1987) Introductory Note to Dubrovskii: Dubrovskii D.I. “The Decipherment of Codes: Methodological Aspects of the Problem”. Journal for The Theory of Social Behaviour. Vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 1–18.