The Righteousness Question of Education

Education is the main institution of society that creates the righteousness and thereby the society itself. The contemporary life nullifies the righteousness and puts existence on the verge of dehumanization; excludes the righteousness from education, making it an institution without-righteousness. The righteousness as such is different from morality, ethics, values. It gives an internal basis for a human being to bear the name “man.” The education must redefine itself in order to become an institution of righteousness. To determine approaches to righteousness transformation of education, this work separates the notions of “spiritual” and “righteous,” “person” and “human” from a philosophical viewpoint. The uncertainty of righteousness is presented as a fundamental question facing the modern education. The reasons for growth of righteousness uncertainty are revealed and designated by categories of impenetrability, spuriousness, covertness, diffuseness, and shiftiness. The article considers experiencing of righteousness as an educational tool for overcoming the righteousness uncertainty. Didactic methods of experiencing the righteousness, managing the ethical risks, and a nuanced approach to ethical dilemmas that underlie the art of righteousness are discussed. The role of experiencing of righteousness in gaining the foresight in distinguishing between good and evil, and in shaping the existential center of personality. The righteous duty of education is defined as upbringing the humanity; issues of righteousness measure and overcoming the anthropocentrism of personality are touched upon. It is shown that the redefinition of Russian education in relation to righteousness and humanity should be based on national culture. The author gives examples of a striking difference between Russian and Western cultures in terms of education, a displacement of righteousness from Russian education by Western models incorporated into it. The negative impact of the Unified State Examination on righteousness in Russian education, on its creative function, and on the scientific-technological development of the country is reviewed. The author concludes that cultivating human qualities should be the primary focus of Russian education. 

1. Albert H. (2010) Treatise on Critical Reason (I.Z. Shishkov, Trans. & Intro.). Moscow: Editorial URSS (Russian translation).

2. Augustine (1998) On the City of God. In: Augustine. Works in 4 Vols. Vol. 3: On the City of God. Books I–XIII (S.I. Eremeeva, Ed.). Saint Petersburg: Aletheia; Kiev: UCIMM-Press (Russian translation).

3. Augustine (2021) On the Trinity. Moscow: Ripol klassik (Russian translation).

4. Berdyaev N.A. (1993) The Destiny of Man: An Essay on Paradoxical Ethics. In: Berdyaev N.A. The Destiny of Man (pp. 19–252). Moscow: Respublika (in Russian).

5. Berdyaev N.A. (1994) The Meaning of Creativity. In: Berdyaev N.A. Philosophy of Creativity, Culture and Art (Vol. 1, pp. 37–342). Moscow: Iskusstvo (in Russian).

6. Berdyaev N.A. (2011) The Realm of Spirit and the Realm of Caesar. In: Berdyaev N.A. Spirit and Reality: Foundations of God-Human Spirituality (pp. 201–344). Minsk: Publishing House of the Belarusian Exarchate (in Russian).

7. Gkeredakis M., Tsoukas H., Swan J., & Nicolini D. (2024, April 3) Want a More Ethical Team? Build Expertise, Not Just Guidelines. MIT Sloan Management Review. No. 65407.

8. Gogol N.V. (1994) Selected Passages from Correspondence with Friends. In: Gogol N.V. Collected Works in 9 Vols. Vol. 6: Spiritual Prose. Criticism. Essays (pp. 5–193). Moscow: Russkaya kniga (in Russian).

9. Gorky M. (1922) On the Russian Peasantry. Berlin: I.P. Ladyzhnikov Publishing House (in Russian).

10. Heidegger M. (1993) The Age of the World Picture. In: Heidegger M. Works and Reflections of Different Years (pp. 135–167). Moscow: Gnozis (Russian translation).

11. Ilyin I.A. (1993) The Path of Spiritual Renewal. In: Ilyin I.A. The Path to Evidence (pp. 133–288). Moscow: Respublika (in Russian).

12. Jung C.G. (2023) The Phenomenology of the Spirit in Fairytales. In: Jung C.G. Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious (pp. 247–303). Moscow: AST (Russian translation).

13. Karpov A.O. (2019) Education in Relation to Truth. Voprosy filosofii. No. 1, pp. 56–66 (in Russian).

14. Karpov A.O. (2023) Knowledge Society: Genesis, Research Education, University 3.0. Moscow: Kanon+ ROOI “Reabilitatsiya” (in Russian).

15. Karpov A.O. (2024a) The Image of Future Education. Voprosy filosofii. No. 1, pp. 17–28 (in Russian).

16. Karpov A.O. (2024b) The Phenomenon of Education: The Existential Order of Being. Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences = Filosofskie nauki. Vol. 67, no. 1, pp. 54–73 (in Russian).

17. Karpov A.O. (2025) The Ontology of the Moral in the Phenomenon of Education. Voprosy filosofii. No. 1, pp. 51–62 (in Russian).

18. Kierkegaard S. (1993) Fear and Trembling. In: Kierkegaard S. Fear and Trembling: Ethical Treatises (pp. 13–112). Moscow: Respublika (Russian translation).

19. Makarenko A.S. (1984) Problems of Soviet School Education (Lectures). In: Makarenko A.S. Pedagogical Works in 8 Vols. Vol. 4: Pedagogical Works of 1936–1939 (pp. 123–203). Moscow: Pedagogika (in Russian).

20. Pruzhinin B.I., Apresyan R.G., Artemyeva O.V., Bakshtanovsky V.I., Gadzhikurbanov A.G., Guseynov A.A., Zubets O.P., Kashnikov B.N., Nazarov V.N., Perov V.Yu., Prokofyev A.V., Razin A.V., Shokhin V.K., & Yudin B.G. (2017) Morality in the Modern World and Problems of Russian Ethics. Conference Materials – “Round Table.” Voprosy filosofii. No. 10, pp. 5–46 (in Russian).

21. Shadrikov V.D. (1999) The Origin of Humanity. Moscow: Logos (in Russian).

22. Zubets O.P. (2022) Prolegomenon to the Philosophical Definition of an Act. Ethical Thought = Eticheskaya mysl’. Vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 5–20 (in Russian).