Right-Wing Anarchism: A Philosophical Left-Wing Concept

The article discusses the issue whether anarchism should be considered a right-wing ideology. Anarchism as an ideology, formulated in the works of Pierre-Joseph Proudhon of the 1830s-1840s, was originally in the leftwing political spectrum. The anarchist Joseph Dejacque, who advocates equality of rights for men and women and does not agree with Proudhon on this issue, called himself a libertaire. The French word libertaire has been translated into English as “libertarian.” Due to the fact that in the 20^th century, economic theories justifying state intervention in the economy became widespread among those who called themselves liberals, the word “liberal” came to mean “socialist.” American liberals (in the original sense of the word) adopted anarcho-communist Dejacque’s neologism “libertarian.” The author shows that, according to the social doctrine of the Catholic Church, unlimited liberalism and socialism have common origins, since these two ideologies proceed from the fact that human freedom is innate, which means that traditional values should not restrict human behavior. Thus, the ideological roots of anarcho-capitalism and libertarianism are to be found in the corpus of doctrines of the French left wing. In the 1970s, the French economist Henri Lepage translated the English word “libertarian” into the French, coining new world libertarien and not using the word libertaire, which is due to the fact that libertarianism began to be perceived as a right-wing ideology, and therefore it was necessary to distinguish it from its roots – libertarisme, which was considered a leftist movement. The author refutes the idea, which became widespread in the 20^th century, that, due to the emergence of the Libertarian party and anarcho-capitalism, a part of the anarchist movement joined the right wing.

1. Bakounine M. (1895) (Euvres (Vol. 1). Paris: Stock (in French).

2. Bakunin M.A. (1906) God and the State. Moscow: Logos (Russian translation).

3. Baudelaire C. (1917) Histoires extraordinaires par Edgar Poe. Paris: Louis Conrad (in French).

4. Baudelaire C. (1906) Lettres 1841-1866. Paris: Mercure de France (in French).

5. Baudelaire C. (2001) Mon cœur mis à nu. Paris: Droz (in French).

6. Blanc de Saint Bonnet A. (1849) De la douleur. Paris: Langlois (in French).

7. Blanc de Saint-Bonnet A. (1872) Restauration frangaise. Paris: La Roche (in French).

8. Blanc de Saint-Bonnet A. (1873) La légitimité. Paris: Librairie internationale catholique (in French).

9. Blanc de Saint-Bonnet A. (1878) Le dix-huitième. Paris: Librairie internationale catholique (in French).

10. Bossuet J.-B. (1852) Histoire des variations des églises protestantes. In: Bossuet J.B. Œuvres (Vol. 4, pp. 1–299). Paris: Firmin Didot Frères (in French).

11. Canto-Sperber M. (1997) Une interprétation de Platon dans l’Angleterre victorienne (1835–1865). In: Neschke-Hentschke A. (Ed.) Images de Platon et lectures de ses œuvres. Les interprétations de Platon à travers les siècles (pp. 315–336). Louvain: Éditions Peeters (in French).

12. Caré S. (2009) La pensée libertarienne. Paris: PUF (in French).

13. Chomsky N. (2001) Réflexions sur l’anarchisme. In: Chomsky N. De l’espoir en l’avenir. Marseille: Agone (French translation).

14. Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church. (2006) Moscow: Paoline, 2006. Retrieved from http://www.caritas-spb.org.ru/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Compendium.pdf (Russian translation).

15. Creagh R. (1981) Histoire de l’anarchisme aux Etats-Unis d’Amérique (1826–1886). Grenoble: La pensée sauvage (in French).

16. Dejacque J. (1857) De l’être-humain mâle et femelle. Retrieved from http://joseph.dejacque.free.fr/ecrits/lettreapjp.htm (in French).

17. Engels F. (1964) Letter to Vera Ivanovna Zasulich, April 23, 1885. In: Marx K. & Engels F. Collected Works (2 nd ed.; Vol. 36, pp. 259–264). Moscow: Politizdat (Russian translation).

18. Foket M. (1987) Regards d’Émile Poulat sur la crise moderniste. A propos de deux livres récents. Revue Théologique de Louvain. Vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 57–69 (in French).

19. Godwin W. (1798) Enquiry Concerning Political Justice and Its Influence on Morals and Happiness (3rd ed.; Vol. 1). London: G.G. and J. Robinson.

20. Hepner B.-P. (1950) Bakounine et le panslavisme révolutionnaire. Paris: Marcel Rivière (in French).

21. Jaurès J. (1901) Histoire socialiste (Vol. 1). Paris: J. Rouff (in French).

22. Jaurès J. (1897) Socialisme et paysans. Paris: E. Crété (in French).

23. Kropotkin P.A. (1920) Modern Science and Anarchy. Peterburg; Moscow: Golos truda (in Russian).

24. Landauer G. (2008) La communauté par le retrait et autres essais. Paris: Editions du Sandre (in French).

25. Lepage H. (2003, August 16) Entretien avec Henri Lepage : Demain le capitalisme. Le Québecois libre. Retrieved from http://www.quebecoislibre.org/030816-3.htm (in French).

26. Maitron J. (1955) Histoire du mouvement anarchiste en France (1880−1914). Paris: SUDEL, 1955 (in French).

27. Malon B. (1895) La Morale sociale. Paris: Giard et Brière (in French).

28. Marx K. (1955) Speech on Freedom of Trade, Delivered at the Public meeting of the Brussels Democratic Association on January 9, 1848. In: Marx K. & Engels F. Collected Works (2 nd ed.; Vol. 4, pp. 404–418). Moscow: Politizdat (Russian translation).

29. Maurois A. (1941) Etudes littéraires. Paris: Editions de la Maison Française (in French).

30. Neschke-Hentschke A. (1997) Introduction. In: Neschke-Hentschke A. (Ed.) Images de Platon et lectures de ses œuvres. Les interprétations de Platon à travers les siècles (pp. XI–XXIII). Louvain: Éditions Peeters (in French).

31. Plekhanov G.V. (1924) Anarchism and Socialism. Krasnodar: Burevestnik (in Russian).

32. Ratzinger J. (2005) Homélie du cardinal Joseph Ratzinger du 18 avril 2005. La Santa Sede. Retrieved from http://www.vatican.va/gpII/documents/homily-pro-eligendo-pontifice_20050418_fr.html

33. Sarda y Salvany F. (1887) Le libéralisme est un péché. Paris: RetanxBray (in French).

34. Schneider H.W. (1955) Histoire de la philosophie américaine. Paris: Gallimard (French translation).

35. Spencer H. (2013) Social Statics. Kyiv: Gama-Print (Russian translation).

36. Strauss L. (2007) Natural Right and History. Moscow: Vodoley Publishers (Russian translation).

37. Thomas Aquinas. (2011) Summa Theologica (Part II–II, questions 1–46). Kyiv: Nika-Tsentr (Russian translation).

38. Tucker B. (1969) Instead of Book, by a Man too Busy to Write One. New York: Haskell House.